What Did Israel's Own Founders Say About God?
Before accepting a biblical mandate — consider what the historical record actually shows
You are being told that supporting the modern state of Israel is a biblical obligation. But here is a question worth sitting with quietly: what did the founders of the modern state of Israel say about God, religion, and the Bible when they created it?
The answer is in the historical record. And it is striking.
Theodor Herzl — the founder of Zionism and the father of the modern state of Israel — met with Pope Pius X. In his own private diary he recorded what he said: “I said that we based our movement solely on the sufferings of the Jews, and wished to put aside all religious issues.” He explicitly asked the Pope to set religion aside entirely. He was not making a biblical argument. He was making a secular, political, humanitarian one.
Israel's founding document cites as its legal basis: the Balfour Declaration, the League of Nations Mandate, the Holocaust, UN Resolution 181, and the right of self-determination. Not one Bible verse. Not one reference to God's covenant. God appears once — in a phrase so deliberately vague that some of Israel's atheist founders argued it could be read as a reference to Karl Marx.
“If the modern state of Israel was founded on explicitly secular, political grounds — by men who refused to put God's name in their founding document — why are you being told that supporting it is a biblical mandate?”
Zionism Is a Political Movement. Dispensationalism Is a 19th-Century Invention.
Neither is ancient biblical doctrine.
Zionism Explained
Zionism is a political movement, not a religious one. It was founded in the 1890s by Theodor Herzl — a secular, non-religious Jewish journalist — to create a homeland for Jewish people suffering from European persecution. Its goals were political and humanitarian. Herzl himself told the Pope he wanted to “put aside all religious issues.”
Over time, language borrowed from scripture was used to build public support — but the political core remained secular. Even Orthodox Jewish communities largely rejected it, arguing that a return to the land before the coming of the Messiah violated Jewish law.
Dispensationalism Explained
Dispensationalism is the theological framework that tells many Christians today that modern Israel is the fulfillment of biblical prophecy and that supporting it is a divine obligation. But this theology did not come from the early Church, from the Church Fathers, or from centuries of Christian tradition. It was invented by John Nelson Darby in the 1830s, popularized through the Scofield Reference Bible in 1909, and only became widespread in American evangelical Christianity in the mid-20th century — notably after Israel was founded in 1948.
The Catholic Church does not hold it. The Eastern Orthodox Church does not hold it. Most mainline Protestant denominations reject it. It is a relatively recent theological innovation.
“If this is an ancient, unchanging biblical truth — why was it only developed 150 years ago? Why did the early Church not teach it? Why do the majority of the world's Christians not hold it?”
What the Bible Actually Says — Brief, Direct
Joshua 21:43 states plainly: “So the Lord gave to Israel all the land of which He had sworn to give to their fathers, and they took possession of it and dwelt in it.” The Bible itself records that God's land promise was fulfilled. No interpretation needed — God said “all,” they possessed it, and they dwelt in it.
Hebrews 11:10 records that Abraham himself, while receiving the earthly promise, was “looking forward to the city with foundations, whose architect and builder is God” — a heavenly city, not a modern parliamentary democracy.
Hebrews 12:22 tells believers: “You have come to Mount Zion, to the city of the living God, the heavenly Jerusalem.” The Jerusalem of the New Covenant is not a political capital managed by a Knesset.
“Is it honest for an organization to claim biblical authority for a project whose founders explicitly rejected biblical authority?”
Know someone who needs to see this?
Share on X